Collaborative Writing of Argumentative Syntheses from Multiple Sources: The Role of Writing Beliefs and Strategies in Addressing Controversy
Martínez, Isabel (1)
Tipo de Ítem:Articulo Revista Indexada
In this study, university students are faced with the task of collaboratively writing an argumentative synthesis from multiple sources. Specifically, in writing, they must integrate conflicting information on a particular issue obtained from reading two texts that present different perspectives. As research in this field has shown, university students' transactional beliefs about writing have a bearing on the quality of the texts that they write. In addition, studies on collaborative learning have demonstrated the role of constructive strategies in addressing controversy. Constructive strategies require an epistemic approach, which implies understanding and integrating opposing positions and rationales. Therefore, the specific aims of the study are to analyze the relationships between the following: (a) writing beliefs and the joint written synthesis, b) writing beliefs and the strategies used to address the controversies that emerge during collaborative writing, and (c) how students resolve controversies and the quality of their joint syntheses. The participants were 52 fourth-year psychology students at a state -run university in Madrid. The results show that transactional writing beliefs are associated with both the controversy strategies employed by members of student dyads and the quality of the joint syntheses. Furthermore, the strategies for addressing controversy are associated with the quality of the joint syntheses.
Este ítem aparece en la(s) siguiente(s) colección(es)
Mostrando ítems relacionados por Título, autor o materia.
Improving Written Argumentative Synthesis by Teaching the Integration of Conflicting Information from Multiple Sources Mateos, Mar; Martin, Elena; Cuevas, Isabel; Villalon, Ruth; Martinez, Isabel (1) (Cognition and Instruction, 2018)The goal of this study was to assess the effectiveness of 2 different types of intervention aimed at improving written argumentative synthesis by integrating conflicting information from different sources. Both interventions ...
Learning history by composing synthesis texts. Effects of an instructional programme on learning, reading and writing processes and text quality Martínez, Isabel (1); Mateos, Mar; Martín, Elena; Rijlaarsdam, Gert (Journal of Writing Research, 07/2015)The combination of reading and writing can be a powerful tool for learning content. Previous research has shown the learning potential of the integrated use of these processes in what have come to be known as "hybrid tasks". ...
González Jara, David; Cuetos Revuelta, María José; Serna Romera, Ana Isabel (UNIVERSIDAD INTERNACIONAL DE LA RIOJA, 02/2015)El ser humano necesita encontrar explicaciones que den sentido a la realidad en la que vive, y la ciencia es una de las herramientas que pueden ayudarle en esa agotadora búsqueda de respuestas que se prolonga a lo largo ...